Pitch & PaveA Harrowgate & Co. company Free audit

Pay-per-lead vs. one monthly price: what contractors should know

By the Harrowgate & Co. team · Pitch & Pave, a Harrowgate & Co. company

Pay-per-lead means you pay for each lead you're sent, whether or not it turns into a job. One monthly price means you pay for the marketing itself (the work, the tools and the ad budget) and judge it by the jobs it books. The right choice depends on what you want to pay for: leads, or the system that brings them in and turns them into booked work.

Request a free 30-minute audit → We'll look at how you get leads today and what each booked job is really costing you.

How pay-per-lead works

You agree on a price per lead, and you're billed for each one you receive. It's simple to start, and you only pay when a lead arrives.

The catch is in what a "lead" is. A lead is a name and a phone number, not a job. Your price, your close rate and your crew decide whether a lead becomes a job, and the lead seller doesn't control any of those. Pay-per-lead also rewards whoever sends the most leads, not the best ones.

How one monthly price works

With one monthly price, you pay for the marketing, not each lead. For the contractors we market, that price covers three things:

  • our team's work;
  • the tools it runs on;
  • your Google and Meta ad budget.

Our team's work includes your plan, ads built and managed every week, town pages, an automatic reply to every web lead within 5 minutes, follow-ups, posts, video and a monthly report in booked jobs.

The tools include call tracking, a text back when you miss a call, and page hosting.

Your written proposal shows your price, everything it includes and how much of it goes to ads, before you sign. Each month, your report shows every ad dollar spent. Any ad budget we don't spend carries forward to the next month.

Instead of a price per lead, we agree on a goal before we start: booked estimates for sealcoaters, and booked roof checks or estimates for roof treatment. If we're behind it, the next month's extra work is on us. Each month, our report shows what each job cost, and the full terms are in your client agreement.

See what one monthly price covers →

The real comparison: cost per booked job

Whichever way you pay, the number that matters is what each booked job cost you. You can work it out for either model:

  • Pay-per-lead: add up what you paid for leads this month, then divide by the jobs those leads booked.
  • One monthly price: our report does it for you, as what you spent and what it booked, so you can see what each job cost.

If a lead source can't tell you how many of its leads became booked jobs, you can't compare it with anything. Track it yourself for a month: mark each lead as booked or not.

Questions to ask before you sign either

  1. What exactly counts as a lead, and what doesn't? Ask about spam, duplicates, existing customers, and requests outside your area or for services you don't offer.
  2. Who else gets the same lead?
  3. Who owns the ad accounts, the phone numbers and the data if you leave?
  4. Will you see what was actually spent on ads?
  5. What's the commitment, and how do you end it?
  6. What does the report count: clicks, leads or booked jobs?

Our answers:

  1. We count real leads only, not spam, duplicates, existing customers, or requests from outside your service area or for services you don't offer.
  2. Your leads come from your own ads, to your own phone numbers and forms.
  3. Your ad accounts, phone numbers, data, pages and paid-for work are yours, even if you leave.
  4. Your report shows every ad dollar spent.
  5. A three-month start, then month to month. After that, 30 days' notice by email is all it takes.
  6. Booked jobs.

When pay-per-lead can make sense

Per-lead pricing isn't always wrong. One channel we use for clients works that way: Google's Local Services Ads, where you're charged per lead and the listing can show at the top of search. It can be a useful part of the mix once Google approves you, alongside your own ads, pages and follow-up, which you control.

Start with a free audit

In 30 minutes we review your website, Google profile, ads and lead follow-up. You keep a written 90-day plan, whether we work together or not.

Request a free 30-minute audit → See the full plan → · How sealcoating companies get more booked jobs →

We don't promise rankings or results. We promise the work, and extra work if we fall behind. Your price comes in a written proposal after the audit.